The German OpenBC (competitor to LinkedIN and others) professional social networking site is running a website design contest for their own site. Everyone can submit a design and a jury plus public vote select a winner who will get $10'000.
What does the online community think about this contest idea?
TechCrunch carried this news and it attracted lots of backlash. Practically all comments were negative, which obviously surprised Michael Arrington quite a bit, saying: " What a terrible, ugly, hateful comment stream." Here a sample:
- "Well, they get 143 designs they now can offer to their users to personalize their pages. There’s nothing new to this “trick”, really."
- "well the designs are pretty boring imho."
- "Professional designers don’t bother with stuff like this. If you want to get a bunch of amateur crap with a contest, go for it. But at the end, you’ll still have amateur crap."
- "when looking back at many projects with German software or web-companies it seems it’s always the same. Pay as little as possible, don’t care about what really counts (user-needs, interaction and workflows), don’t care about a process - just make it pretty. The other extreme there is over-engineering (hello frauenhofer-usability fraction) until the core of boredom is revealed and let loose on the end-loser."
Looks like this publicity did not go well with the professional community that they are serving. Although OpenBC positions itself as a community site for professionals, I heard from many users now that the community is actually primarily low-profile people who are looking for a job, offering their services and hoping to chat with a "celebrity" in OpenBC, which of course does not actually happen. I must admit that I have not tried it myself so the above is really only a collection of other people's opinions, but ones that I can trust. The thing I noticed myself is that LinkedIn regularly sends me invitations to work with my - totally neglected - account and also to get many people trying to network with me. This never happened with OpenBC which is at the least a bit odd, I think. I am probably not a typical OpenBC guy: Oh well!